On todays HockeyCentral at noon, Mike Brophy did the best job of putting my thoughts to words.
Hits to the head, and predatory hitting.
This is a major issue, and trust me, I’m no shrinking violet who doesn’t enjoy the physical side of the game, but I’m also not a blood lust kinda guy who finds any enjoyment, whatsoever, in seeing a player laid out in a predatory hit, and leaving the ice on a stretcher. I love this GAME. I don’t love the idea of a person suffering a life long injury for no good reason, and least of all for my entertainment.
Some argue, and fairly, that every player who skates onto the ice knows the risk they’re taking, and in going over the boards, accept this risk.
Fair enough…but to a point.
I know, when I drive my car, I could get into an accident, where the other driver, or myself, did not do anything purposely wrong to cause the accident. I know this could cause my death, or a life long injury. I drive every day.
But I don’t expect somebody to T-bone me, if I run a red light by accident, because they can. Honestly, if they sped up, knowing I was running the red, so they could hit me, for whatever reason, they’d, legally, still be in the clear (unless I could prove their intent, which I can’t).
This is the same for a player who makes a predatory hit. They know they can, they know it would be impossible to prove they meant to hurt the player, and so they get away with a “clean-hit”.
But, it wasn’t clean. We ALL know that.
In all likelihood, that hit could have been made, in such a way as to remove the player from the puck, and probably even make a good “show”, without running them over.
So what’s to stop a player from making the hit to hurt vs. the hit to both win, and entertain? Seeing a player hurt is NOT entertaining. It’s sickening.
I can tell you honestly, if a player was “hit to hurt” every game, resulting in a stretcher evac…I’d quit watching, and I’m a guy who loves the UFC.
So, how do we deal with this?
One way is the OHL way, where by, after the recent predatory hit on a player, D. Branch suspended the offending player for a year. Now, that’s heavy handed, but here’s what Broph had to say about it, and I agree completely;
“It’s a tough one (the suspension), and I feel very, very bad for Mike Liambas (the hitter) because , as I said to David Branch (OHL Commish.) when I spoke to him yesterday, I was working the night of the hit, and we all got ‘hey, did you hear what happened in an OHL game?’, and we went over (to review the hit)…I’ve seen way worse hits…(goes on to tell some stories of past hits in the OHL). At the end of the day, here’s where I go with this one, the game has changed. Because they’ve (the OHL) opened the game up, they don’t allow players to hook and hold, so you can’t hold guys up anymore. Players need a reason, they need a reason to stop, for one split second and think about what they’re doing on the ice, and now they have that reason. Micheal Liambas, unfortunately, you can call him a scapegoat, or whatever, but players now have a reason to stop and think before they hit a player who’s in a vulnerable position, and as I say, this is not the worst thing I’ve ever seen, obviously the result of the hit was horrible, with this young man lying in a hospital today…That’s what David Branch has done, he’s given players a reason to stop and think before they act…it blows my mind when you see players who are vulnerable, and players attack…they’re only doing what they’re instructed to do by their coaches,’take your man out, and take him out hard’. But now they have a reason to stop and think about how hard they’re going to take a guy out, it could cost you a season”
Yeah, some will say it’s a slippery slope, but c’mon, this is life and death were talking about, and there’s nothing slippery about that.
The laws of cause and effect dictate that you cannot remove one aspect of the game, without there being some result. Sure, the reason was to improve the skill, and increase scoring opportunities, all laudable objectives, but, unforeseeable, it has created this other issue, and it’s about time the NHL acknowledges the reality of the situation, and acts in a responsible manner to mitigate this new risk. Undoubtedly the players need to do the same, and behave with more concern for the safety of each-other, and by default, themselves, but as long as the NHL allows it, the management will demand it, and a multi-million dollar lifestyle is one hell of a motivation to do what you’re told to do.
GN